It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that Otago Daily Times cartoonist Garrick Tremain has been hung out to
dry – or as seems to be the preferred metaphor these days, thrown under a bus.
I get the impression that Tremain now accepts that his
cartoon making light of the Samoan measles epidemic was grossly
insensitive. But he’s hardly the only person culpable.
All newspaper cartoons are supposed to be vetted by senior editorial
people and we can assume that process was followed in this case, in which case
editorial heads should be rolling too, metaphorically speaking.
The paper not only failed to see how wrong the cartoon was but
also misjudged the public reaction, thinking it could get away with a low-key
apology on page 10. The editor, Barry Stewart, has since tried to make amends
by facing protesters yesterday and publishing a second mea culpa on the front
page today.
But it’s Tremain who’s being made to bear the primary
responsibility. Stewart says the cartoonist has been stood down while the ODT
conducts a “review”, which sounds like a damage control exercise aimed at
mollifying protesters in the hope that it will all blow over.
A particularly ignoble aspect of the controversy is the
spectacle of a fellow cartoonist putting the boot in. Jim Hubbard has drawn not
one but two cartoons taking a whack at Tremain, which strikes me as contemptible.
Hubbard’s cartoons are often close to the bone too, though at
the opposite end of the political spectrum from Tremain’s, and it’s not hard to
envisage circumstances in which he too might be publicly pilloried, in which
case I’m sure he would appreciate a bit of solidarity.
As an aside, I can’t help wondering whether the ODT's display of tone-deafness over
the Tremain cartoon is a Dunedin thing. No offence to the ODT – a paper for which I have great respect – or to the residents
of that estimable city, but Dunedin is a bit isolated from the cultural
mainstream and possibly not quite in tune with how issues are viewed in other
parts of the country. Could that explain the ODT’s spectacular lapse of judgment?